Sea of ​​Thieves Review – It’s a Pirates Life for Me!

Anchor's on-board and our rags are all set...


Sea of Thieves is a colourful pirate adventure where you go loot with friends and compete against other players. I played the release version with a few loyal shipmates to find out if the game is only a short-term comedy affair or if we can expect a long-term playable experience.

Sea of Thieves is the highly-anticipated multiplayer-based open-world adventure game where you play the role of a pirate. The basic goals are to plunder, defeat skeleton-pirates and rise to become the fiercest pirate on the thieving seas! In addition to the actual treasure hunt or the exciting sea battles, Sea of Thieves focuses on one major element: teamwork.

Teamwork is very important in Sea of Thieves. From the beginning, the game encourages players to play with a headset to enjoy the full pirate experience. This is sorely needed as in order to control such a large pirate ship effectively, you need several people and good communication. On a big Galleon ship, you really need four players. One player takes the wheel and steers the ship, another is needed to adjust the sails and ensure the best speeds. You also need a player watching the map and another at the helm making sure the ship doesn’t crash into any of the many obstacles plaguing the sea.

Sea of Thieves Players Need to Work Together to Steer the Ship
In Sea of Thieves, Players Need to Work Together to Steer the Ship

Anyone who has counted correctly already recognises the dilemma: steering the ship, navigating the map, adjusting the sails, keeping a lookout and managing cannons/livestock or any other cargo – these are already five tasks. This means that communication is essential to managing a big ship. This ensures that you are constantly communicating with your teammates. Even if you have had no enemy contact for 20 minutes, there is always something to do.

Let’s Go On a Treasure Hunt

One of the main focuses of Sea of Thieves is the search for treasure. Once the ship’s inventory is loaded up with bananas, cannonballs and planks (for repair purposes) we are nearly ready to set sail. You can purchase quests from a dealer. Starting off most of these are free and can be completed quickly. As you level up and complete more of them, however, they begin getting longer (and thus result in better plunder). In the beta, there was only the classic treasure hunt, where you usually had to find a specific island, and then solve this on a puzzle. In the beginning, the puzzles became more and more demanding as the level increased, but mostly solvable.

There are several different types of quests that you can choose. The ones I have done so far were the treasure quests and a couple hunt missions (where you have to hunt down a dead pirate captain with a glowing skull face). With the others, we also had a quest to go find a white feathered chicken and a few other things but the team was split between Discord and the Xbox Party Chat system which made the quest impossible to complete.

Once you have finished the treasure hunt you need to (temporarily) store your chest on the ship. During the beta, I played solo a lot and ended up getting my chests stolen but yesterday a viewer in the stream told me I should hide them in the crows nest as no-one looks there. That was probably the best tip I have ever gotten about a game, (that’s a lie, the best tip I ever got was how to find the singing grunt in Halo 5).

The chests can be brought to the nearest commercial outpost. If you haven’t gotten involved in a fight or have survived one unscathed, you can sell them at a trade guild. Remember to stock up on new items and buy a new order (quest) while you’re at it. The hunt missions are completed the same way, simply pick up the glowing skull from the dead pirate captain and store it somewhere on the ship. The skull can be sold the same way as selling a chest.

The world of Sea of Thieves is full of breathtaking scenery
The world of Sea of Thieves is full of breathtaking scenery

Ahoy, Ye Landlubbers!

The game’s scenery is one of my favourite things about the game. The sunsets and lightning storms are extremely realistic and add to the whole immersion of the game. This helps immeasurably when your playing by yourself and have to sail to a far-off island. Where there is a drop of action and plundering, players can admire their surroundings. The level of detail that went into this game is immediately evident and rewarding to all players.

What makes Sea of Thieves different from many multiplayer games like Rust and DayZ is the fact that its players aren’t as volatile. In Sea of Thieves, taking on another player requires careful planning to ensure that the attacking player comes out on top. This means that you can easily play by yourself and not have to worry about a group of players who got together just to make other players experience miserable.

At Gamescom last year I got some hands-on with Sea of Thieves in the Xbox booth with some of the Elite Gamer team. The devs were great and it was clear that they really care about their community. They explained how some of their mechanics worked and how a lot of their features got developed by community support. The game also won our “Best PC Game” award at Gamescom too. The PC support during the Alpha was a large contributor to this decision.

Sea of Thieves is very much a community-driven game. From the very start they opened their game up to players to ensure became the final result is exactly what the players asked for. The forums are where a lot of the magic happened, this is where insider players came together to discuss in-game bugs, improvements and to share ideas for stuff they would like to see in-game.

Play Shanties in High-C

A great feature of the game is the ability to play music. Players can choose between a squeezebox or a lute (for now) and play a selection of different songs. Whats more is when more than one player is playing instruments, they all sync up and it sounds magical.

If you haven’t already, I highly recommend giving Sea of Thieves a try. It’s a great game to play on your own and an even better game to play with friends. I’ve been playing it since it’s early Alpha phase right up to the final Beta last week. What I love most is that even though I’ve been playing it for a while, going into the official release version felt like playing a whole new game. The visuals were improved and there was far more to do in the game than there was in the Beta.

The game is available now on the Xbox store and the Windows 10 store. It’s a “Play Anywhere” title so if you buy it on Xbox you can also play it on your PC. Whats more, users with the Xbox Game Pass can play it right now as well. There is even a 14-day free trial available for new subscribers. So what are you waiting for Matey? Set Sail and Ship Out!

Formats: Xbox One (reviewed) and PC
Price: €69.99
Publisher: Microsoft Studios
Developer: Rare
Release Date: 20th March 2018
Age Rating: 12


  1. the game is alot of fun i tested the beta for a while …alone and it wasnt nowhere near as fun

    with 3-4 people this game is a complete blast , no progression or traditional leveling like an rpg

    just go out and kill shit get gold and have a ton of genuine fun moments with your mates.

    in the time i played i had alot of moments that i wont be able to replicate , and tons of laughs … the

    devs didnt sell us a destiny story with this game they basically said what this game would be.

  2. seeing more reviews pop in, how do you feel about being basically the only positive score (and a 9/10 at that), do you feel like the game really clicked for you? or… is there a reason for such a difference between scores? Edit: no hostility just kinda curious if sometimes you look back on reviews and say “huh, maybe I should’ve given it more/less”

    • I’m sorry this review is overscored and poorly written no negs whatsoever. For a early access barebones game. It reviewers such as this why we get unfinished games..

      He not really score this game in the state of an early access game, but what it will become in 6/12 months time. Me thinks.